You bought a gym membership and stopped going
It's a familiar story: in January you buy a yearly membership, go for the first few weeks, and by spring the card sits in your wallet doing nothing. You're not the only one. Economists Stefano DellaVigna and Ulrike Malmendier even called their paper “Paying Not to Go to the Gym”. They compared which membership people choose with how often they actually go. The gap turned out to be big, and by then the money had already been paid
Below we look at why this happens and when people usually quit. Then we look at what to do with a membership that gathers dust: freeze it, get money back, transfer it to a friend or sell the rest. For selling there is Repass by the 1Fit team, a free bulletin board where you can sell a gym membership or buy what someone else has left. It's repass.fit worldwide and repass.kz in Kazakhstan. The club, chain and service names in this article belong to their owners, and Repass isn't affiliated with those clubs and chains
Why we pay for a gym we don't go to
The authors put it down to overconfidence. When we buy a membership, we picture our future self: organised, full of energy and with free evenings. So unlimited access seems sure to pay off. We also believe we'll cancel a monthly plan right away if we stop going, but in practice we put it off. There's no reason to blame yourself, plenty of people do the same. It's more useful to know about this trap in advance and choose a membership for how often you go now, not for how often you'd like to
The economists used data from three US health clubs: which contract 7,752 members chose and how they attended over three years. Members paying over $70 a month came on average 4.3 times a month and paid more than $17 per visit, while a 10-visit pass worked out at $10 a visit. Over their membership these people missed out on $600 of savings on average. Those who chose a monthly contract so they could leave at any time were 17% more likely to stay beyond a year than those who signed a yearly contract
DellaVigna S, Malmendier U, Am Econ Rev, 2006When we buy matters too. Hengchen Dai, Katy Milkman and Jason Riis described the “fresh start effect”: after landmark dates people search Google for “diet” more often, go to the gym more often and set themselves new goals more often. Such dates are the start of a week, month or year, a birthday or a holiday. That's why it feels so right to start in January or on a Monday. This year Black Friday falls on 27 November. Before you buy a yearly membership for the discount, recall how many times a week you actually went before. And even after a good start, life gets in the way:
- A move: in a new city or neighbourhood the old club is out of your way
- A new gym: another club turned out closer or more convenient, and the old membership is still running
- An injury or illness: you can't train for now, but the membership days keep going
- A new job: your schedule changed and you just don't make it to the gym
- No time: a busy season, studies or family take up every evening
When people quit and what to do with the membership
Most people quit in the first months, as the data from a club in Brazil below show. The membership keeps running, so decide right away. You have four options: freeze it, get money back, transfer it to a friend or sell the rest. What's allowed is in your club's contract or public offer, and the rules differ everywhere. Under the S89Fitness public offer, for example, a membership can be transferred to another person once for free through the club's app. The terms of the British chain PureGym and the German chain McFIT say the membership is personal and can't be transferred. So check with your club first
The researchers studied the records of 5,240 members of one fitness center in Rio de Janeiro from 2005 to 2014 and followed each of them for 12 months or until they left. 63% of new members quit before the third month, and fewer than 4% kept going for more than 12 months in a row. The risk of quitting depended on age, previous activity, starting body mass index and the goals people came with. Even people with the best mix of these factors still had a high risk of quitting within the first year
Sperandei S, Vieira MC, Reis AC, J Sci Med Sport, 2016Plan B: walking is free If the gym turned out not to be for you, you can stay active without a membership. In a meta-analysis of 15 cohorts (Paluch et al., 2022), more steps a day went with a lower risk of death from any cause until the benefit levelled off at about 6,000-8,000 steps for people aged 60 and over and 8,000-10,000 for younger adults. The Qozgal app will count your steps. After an injury or with a chronic illness, talk to your doctor about the load first
How to sell a gym membership on Repass
First ask your club whether it allows a transfer and what it costs. Then add the club, the term left and your price on Repass. Add the club's price for the same term and buyers see the saving in percent. Add freeze days, the re-registration fee and who pays it, plus 1 to 8 photos of the card or contract with names, numbers and signatures covered. Posting is free, a daily bump to the top of your city feed is free too, and buyers call or text you. Post it now, before the term is up. In Kazakhstan you can sell or buy a gym membership second hand on repass.kz
| Option | When it fits | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Freeze | You need a break: a holiday, an illness, a business trip | How many freeze days you have left and how to switch the freeze on |
| Refund | You won't go anymore and the club gives money back | How much you get back and what the contract lets the club keep |
| Transfer to a friend | A friend or relative wants the membership | Whether the club allows transfers and what it charges |
| Sell the rest | You won't go, and a refund is poor value or not possible | Club rules, term left, freeze days and the re-registration fee |
A membership in your wallet doesn't make you stronger. A sold one at least gives some of the money back
How to buy a gym membership second hand without the risk
Buying a membership second hand makes sense when you want a specific club and it allows transfers. It could be a chain like Invictus, FitnessBlitz, World Class or Hero’s Journey, a club with a pool like Wellness Club LUXOR, or a yoga studio or school like Happy Yoga, Yoga Om or Pradnya Institute of Yoga. Memberships like these are also sold on OLX, in Telegram chats and Instagram stories, on Kleinanzeigen in Germany and on Craigslist in the US. There you dig the term, freeze days and transfer fee out of the text or ask in messages. On Repass they have their own fields, and you see everything before you call
- Open your city's feed and search for the club by name: in Almaty, for example, KRIDA, D-fitness, Banzai or Adrenaline, in Astana Underground Big, Champion Fitness or Iron Club, in Shymkent Sport Life, OnFit or Royal Club Fitness & Spa
- Check the end date or the visits left, the freeze days, the re-registration fee and the saving in percent in the listing
- Tap “Show contacts” and agree with the seller by phone, Telegram or WhatsApp
- Ask for a photo of the contract or card with personal data covered, and call the club to ask whether the membership can be transferred to you and what it costs
- Go to the club together and do the transfer with the staff
- Pay only after the club has confirmed the transfer
- In a study of three US clubs, unlimited plans cost more than paying per visit because people overestimated how often they would go
- At a club in Rio de Janeiro, 63% of new members quit before the third month, while the membership keeps running
- An unused membership leaves you four options: freeze it, get money back, transfer it or sell the rest, and your club's contract sets the rules
- A buyer checks the listing, calls the club and pays only after the club has confirmed the transfer
- Post your membership on Repass for free: at repass.fit worldwide and at repass.kz in Kazakhstan
Frequently asked questions
Can I transfer a gym membership to someone else?
It depends on the club. Some allow it, some charge a re-registration fee and some don't allow it at all. International chains such as Planet Fitness, Basic-Fit, Anytime Fitness, Gold's Gym, Equinox, Virgin Active, F45 or Orangetheory set their own rules too. Check your club's or chain's terms before you sell. The transfer is done at the club itself, Repass doesn't check it. If the club charges a fee, put it in the listing and say who pays it
How do I buy a gym membership second hand without getting scammed?
Repass doesn't check people, clubs or memberships, so check everything yourself. Ask for a photo of the contract or card with personal data covered, compare the term, price and fees with the listing and ask the club whether the membership can be transferred. Do the transfer at the club and pay only once the club has confirmed it. If you see a scam, report the listing or block the seller in the app
How much does Repass cost?
Posting is free, and you can bump each listing to the top of your city feed for free once a day. Repass doesn't take or hold the money for the membership: the buyer pays the seller directly
Can I sell a 1Fit subscription?
You can post it: pick 1Fit as the type, add the end date and your price, and the plan name if you like. Whether a subscription can change hands depends on 1Fit, so check its rules before you post. Repass doesn't check this
How do I get money back for an unused gym membership?
Look at your club's contract or public offer: it says whether money is refunded and what is kept. For example, under the S89Fitness public offer an early termination doesn't refund the membership fee, which is 30% of the price, and the months already used are recounted at the regular monthly price. Other clubs have their own terms, so ask yours. If there's no refund or it comes out small, think about selling the rest
Where can I download Repass?
Repass is an app for iPhone and Android. To see where to download it, go to repass.fit, or to repass.kz in Kazakhstan. You must be 18 or older to use it
Sources
- DellaVigna S, Malmendier U. “Paying Not to Go to the Gym”, American Economic Review, 2006 Am Econ Rev 2006
- Sperandei S, Vieira MC, Reis AC. “Adherence to physical activity in an unsupervised setting: explanatory variables for high attrition rates among fitness center members”, Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport, 2016 J Sci Med Sport 2016
- Dai H, Milkman KL, Riis J. “The Fresh Start Effect: Temporal Landmarks Motivate Aspirational Behavior”, Management Science, 2014 Manag Sci 2014
- Paluch AE et al. “Daily steps and all-cause mortality: a meta-analysis of 15 international cohorts”, The Lancet Public Health, 2022 Lancet Public Health 2022
